Chautauqua Attempted Murder, Assault Trial Postponed

Submitted by Justin Gould on Wed, 01/03/2024 - 13:28

MAYVILLE, NY – The trial for Hadi Matar, 26, of New Jersey, was postponed Wednesday morning by Chautauqua County Court Judge David W. Foley, so that manuscripts related to a memoir about the August 2022 assault can be subpoenaed.

Hadi Matar“Judge Foley postponed the trial, to a date to be determined, to afford the defense an opportunity to attempt to obtain certain materials underlying the planned publication of Mr. Salman Rushdie’s upcoming book, entitled “Knife,” in which he recounts the stabbing attack committed upon him on August 12, 2022. Any written or recorded statements concerning the attack, made by any witness, is discoverable information. In this case, the defense was aware of the planned publication since mid-October but only recently asked the Court to allow them time to attempt to obtain a copy of the manuscript by subpoena,” explained Chautauqua County District Attorney Jason Schmidt while speaking to the media following the hearing.

Chautauqua County Public Defender Ned Barone, Matar’s attorney, first sought the delay during a pre-trial court appearance on Tuesday.

“A last minute adjournment of the trial is frustrating without question, since every trial presents numerous moving parts, and this one is particularly complex given security concerns and that many of the witnesses we’ve subpoena’d are located outside of and across New York State. I and my office have been prepping for trial for months now, including through the holiday season.  We were ready for jury selection this upcoming Monday.  To have to restart that engine several months down the road, and put this all back together again, is in my view a tremendous waste of resources for the County to absorb but I can assure the public it will not change the ultimate outcome,” continued DA Schmidt.

While the subpoena process is underway, Matar will remain in custody at the Chautauqua County Jail.  Matar is charged with second-degree attempted murder and second-degree assault.

Video of District Attorney Schmidt’s press gaggle following Wednesday’s court appearance is available to view on Chautauqua County’s YouTube page and for direct download at this link: Chautauqua Attempted Murder, Assault Trial Postponed 010324


News Categories

News Feed

Violent Felony Weapons Sentencing

Cody Boisvert, age 25 of Jamestown, was sentenced yesterday in Chautauqua County court by Judge David Foley to an determina

Sentencing Issued in Felony Weapons Case

Jimmy Watts, age 49 of Dunkirk, was sentenced yesterday, April 9th, to a determinate state prison sentenced of 8

Jamestown Man Sentenced In Felony Drug Case

MAYVILLE, NY – Todd Dalton, 39, of Jamestown, was sentenced Monday by Judge David Foley to four years in state pris

Jamestown Burglary Convict Receives 10-Year State Prison Sentence

MAYVILLE, NY - District Attorney Jason Schmidt announced Tuesday that William Buckley of Jamestown, New York, was s

Nine Count Indictment Unsealed, Alleging Sexual Acts Against a Child

MAYVILLE, NY - District Attorney Jason Schmidt announced Thursday the unsealing of a nine count indictment handed u

Man Sentenced For Jamestown, NY Shooting Death

MAYVILLE, NY -- Friday, January 12th, Kevin Roldan Pantojas of Jamestown,